Paragraph Scoring Criteria


Paragraphs and Discussions Ideas and Support
7.5
Communication of Ideas
2.5
  The student . . .
Excellent  
  • provides thoughtful ideas and thorough explanations
  • uses specific, relevant, and accurate support
  • demonstrates a confident and perceptive understanding of task

7.5

 
  • organizes writing fluently and effectively
  • uses precise, accurate, and effective vocabulary
  • demonstrates confident control of sentence construction, grammar, and mechanics

2.5

Proficient  
  • provides meaningful ideas and appropriate explanations
  • uses relevant and appropriate support that may contain minor errors
  • demonstrates proficient and clear understanding of task

6

 
  • organizes writing proficiently
  • uses specific, accurate, and appropriate vocabulary
  • demonstrates proficient control of sentence construction, grammar, and mechanics

2

Satisfactory  
  • provides straightforward ideas and general explanations
  • uses relevant but general and/or incompletely developed support
  • demonstrates acceptable understanding of task

4.5

 
  • organizes writing clearly and functionally
  • uses appropriate and generally accurate but unspecific vocabulary
  • demonstrates satisfactory control of sentence construction, grammar, and mechanics

1.5

Limited  
  • provides limited and over-generalized ideas and/or explanation
  • uses superficial support that may not always be relevant
  • demonstrates limited understanding of task

3

 
  • organizes writing unevenly and /or incompletely
  • uses general and/or imprecise and/or inappropriate vocabulary
  • demonstrates faltering control of sentence construction, grammar, and mechanics

1

Poor  
  • provides minimal and/or poorly related ideas and/or explanation
  • uses superficial, incomplete, and/or marginally relevant support, if any
  • demonstrates minimal understanding of task

1.5

 
  • organizes writing unclearly and ineffectively
  • uses ineffective and frequently incorrect vocabulary
  • demonstrates lack of control of sentence construction, grammar, and mechanics

0.5