4.1.7 Emergence of Communism in Russia

Russia was the largest country in the world, with a diverse geography, resources and cultures. It had been ruled by absolute monarchs and the Russian aristocracy for centuries. Most Russians were illiterate peasants who could not vote. Historically, most Russians had been serfs, labourers who were forced to work in the homes and fields of landowners in return for their protection. They had little or no income, few legal rights, and, therefore, little power over their own lives. Russia had not industrialized at the same rate as other European nations, and wealth was very unevenly distributed. In the mid-nineteenth century, the empire of the Romanov family comprised more than one-sixth of the earth's surface. It was a "whole world, self-sufficient, independent, and absolute" with the greatest wealth in Europe. Czar (sometimes spelled Tsar or Tzar) Nicholas II opposed Western ideas, including democratization.

Emancipation of the Serfs

In 1861, a huge liberal reform occurred with the emancipation of the serfs. Twenty-three million serfs were given the rights of citizens, including the right to marry without the consent of the landowner, the right to own property, and the right to own a business. Peasants who had been field workers could buy land from the landlords; household serfs gained their freedom but no land. However, this change was not entirely successful because many freed serfs could not afford to buy enough land that would feed their families. They borrowed money to buy land, and their loan payments were far more than they could afford.

Russian Revolution of 1905

© Around the Winter Palace,Michail I. Avilov.
Courtesy International Institute of Social History, Netherlands
In January 1905, unarmed workers and their families marched peacefully to the palace to petition for greater rights. Led by a Russian priest, Father Gapon, the workers asked for better working conditions, an eight-hour working day, fairer wages, and the right to vote. Influenced by liberal ideals, their demands were similar to demands of working people all over Europe. Unlike their counterparts in other nations, however, the people of Russia were not met with democratic reform. Instead, they were gunned down by the Imperial Guard in a massacre now known as Bloody Sunday in which at least 1000 people were killed.


©ADLC, Adapted from Perspectives on Ideologies/Understandings of Ideologies, Oxford Canada. 

 

 



Bloody Sunday triggered a wide range of reactions in the Russian Revolution of 1905. Protests, strikes by workers, and ethnic uprisings occurred across the country, leading to the eventual establishment of the Duma, or Russian parliament. Although the Czar promised greater freedoms for the people and power to the elected government, in reality he had no desire to give up his absolute control of the country.


Learn more about Russia before the 1917 Revolution. This provides insight into WHY many Russian people rejected liberal principles in favour of communism by the 1920s.


"Russia Before the 1917 Revolution: The Great War Special", The Great War, You-tube 

 

 



Failure of Democratic Reforms

The first Duma lasted for only ten weeks. The second Duma was composed of Social Democrats, Social Revolutionaries, and members of the right wing. Accused by the Prime Minister of plotting an armed overthrow of the Czar, the second Duma was dissolved quickly. New rules that gave greater power to landowners ensured that the rich had greater control, so the unrepresentative Third Duma lasted for its full five years.

World War I began in 1914, causing more problems for the Russian people. Food shortages, strikes by workers, and huge losses in the war all caused great anger towards the Czar. As in other industrializing countries, many farm workers had moved to the cities, resulting in a large urban labour force, many of whom were unemployed and starving. There was also a growing class of business people and professionals. These people were influenced increasingly by new and revolutionary political ideas.

Provisional Government

The Fourth Duma agreed to suspend its operation for the duration of World War I, but its members became increasingly unhappy with the way the Czar and the military were handling national affairs. The February Revolution of 1917 led to the abdication of the Czar and the formation of the Russian Republic. Its government was called the Provisional Government, also sometimes known as the Kerensky Government after its leader, a prominent socialist.

Although most Russians wanted to see Russia withdraw immediately from the war, it launched a new offensive instead, weakening its public support. The government was victim of a power struggle between left and right. Economic chaos added to the problems. Production decreased, industries shut down, the cost of living increased, and there was mass unemployment. Many of those who still had jobs went on strike. Foreign debt skyrocketed, and the country was on the verge of bankruptcy.

Russian Revolution 1917

By the fall of 1917, thousands of peasant uprisings were directed against landowners and attempts to punish the rioters enraged them more. Soldiers and sailors declared they no longer recognized the authority of the Provisional Government and refused to follow orders. The October Revolution of 1917 saw Lenin's Bolsheviks take power and a civil war followed from 1917 to 1922. It ended with the formation of the Soviet Union.

During this time of turmoil, revolutionary groups assassinated political leaders and civil servants, and the government responded by executing those they thought were responsible. More than 10 000 people were assassinated or executed. The failure of capitalism and one unsuccessful parliament after another led the Russian people to consider other ideological perspectives.

Communism emerged in the Soviet Union partly as a rejection of liberalism but also as a rejection of a capitalist system based on hereditary wealth and power in which the average citizen was poor, owned very little property, and had little or no autonomy. One Duma after another, followed by the more democratic Provisional Government, showed the people that parliamentary democracy was ineffective and would not bring about any real change.


Copyright Learn Everywhere, Alberta Education. For a more comprehensive timeline click here.

Read in your text Perspectives on Ideology.
  • pages 164 to 165 - the massacre of Russian workers
  • pages 168 to 170 - "The Need for Change in Russia"
  • pages 169 to 170 - "Lenin and the Rise of Communism"
  • pages 170 to 171 - "Ineffectual Reform"
  • pages 171 to 172 - "Communism is Established"

As you read, take notes on the following:
  • What values and beliefs lie behind the ideology of communism?
  • Why did the Russian people reject liberalism in favour of communism?


Watch this short video that explains the rise to power of two founders of Communist Russia - Lenin and Trotsky. What factors shaped their ideology? What led to the civil war in Russia that eventually established communism?


""Lenin & Trotsky- Their Rise to Power- Who Did What in WWI?", The Great War, You-tube 

 

 



Lenin and Leninist Thought

Vladimir Lenin at Smolny, 1925.
© Courtesy Scholar's Resource

Lenin is considered to be the father of communist Russia. He was influenced strongly by the ideas of Karl Marx and Frederich Engels, but he developed other theories of his own. His brand of communism, known as Leninism, differs significantly from Marxism. He was the first President of the Union of the Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR).

Marxist theory and Lenin's communism differ. Marx believed that the working class would naturally rise up on their own to take over the means of production. Decades after Marx wrote The Communist Manifesto, Lenin did not see the proletarian revolution happening in Russia. His country was not industrialized, and most people were illiterate peasants.

In most of the Western world, the working class was getting richer and obtaining more rights and political power. Lenin believed that the Russian proletariat or peasant was not achieving its fair share of power. Because most working people laboured for 10 to 12 hours per day, they did not have the time or the education to develop a full understanding of communist theory. At best, they would be able only to organize themselves into trade unions to fight for pay and working conditions. To gain the power over society they deserved, they would need to be led into revolution by a highly disciplined group of intellectuals. This was a divergence from Marxist theory into Leninist communism.

Lenin believed that led by him, his Bolshevik party would lead Russia into a communist society based on egalitarianism. Learn more about how Lenin rejected liberal principles and established a communist dictatorship.


Download, print, and take notes on Lenin here.


How the communists developed their support base

Russia was a huge and mostly rural country with a limited communications network and a high rate of illiteracy. How did the communist government reach the masses to deliver its message about the promise of a socialist state? The communist government used visual images to reach the general population with a number of simple messages. These simple, colourful posters achieved several goals.

To consolidate power, the government identified the enemies of communism, provided educational messages about hygiene, health care, and agricultural production, and encouraged solidarity and support for the communist party. Through these posters, the communists encouraged the peasants and factory workers to support the communist movement and its promise for a fairer world.   See sample posters and their messages here.

After considering the context in which Soviet communism developed, think about the issue question:
To what extent was resistance to liberalism justified in Russia?